What’s Wrong With This Picture? — Seven Strange Facts About One of America’s Most Iconic Paintings

Washington Crossing the Delaware -- an American painting? Not quite.
“Washington Crossing the Delaware”. A classic American painting? Umm… not quite.

“The future first president’s famous boat ride was immortalized in an iconic 22-foot-wide painting entitled ‘Washington Crossing the Delaware’. Almost as interesting as the actual feat itself is the story behind the artwork.”

PERHAPS THE MOST celebrated moment of George Washington’s military career was his surprise attack on Trenton, New Jersey the day after Christmas in 1776. Yet for many, the centrepiece of this memorable victory isn’t the battle itself, but rather his crossing of the ice-choked Delaware River the night before.

The 10-hour nighttime operation saw 2,400 Continental troops traverse an 800-foot wide stretch of water between Upper Makefield, Pennsylvania and Titusville, New Jersey. They were carried by a flotilla of rowboats and barges, all of which that were begged, borrowed or stolen from local residents. The entire undertaking was complicated by a winter storm.

Once safely on the opposite bank, Washington’s soaked and shivering army marched four hours in the pre-dawn gloom to surprise and overwhelm 1,500 Hessian mercenaries wintering in Trenton.

The ensuing skirmish lasted only minutes. When it was over, Washington’s rag-tag army had taken the town and netted nearly 1,000 prisoners. Although only a minor victory militarily, the triumph served to reinvigorate the flagging rebellion, which up until that point seemed all but doomed.

The future first president’s famous boat ride was later immortalized in an iconic 22-foot-wide painting entitled “Washington Crossing the Delaware.” And perhaps almost as interesting as the actual feat-of-arms itself is the story behind the artwork celebrating it. Consider these facts:

Emanuel Leutze. (Image source: WikiCommons)

1. It wasn’t painted by an American

The quintessentially American oil-on-canvas was actually painted by an immigrant. A German artist by the name of Emanuel Leutze completed it in 1851 – a full 75 years after the events he depicted had occurred. Leutze, who was born in Württemberg in 1816, lived in Philadelphia for a time and was enthralled by the history of North America. His other works included “The Battle of Monmouth” and the epic “Westward Ho.” Something of a political revolutionary in his own right, Leutze hoped his dramatic rendition of a key moment in the American War of Independence might inspire Europe’s downtrodden workers to rise again in rebellion following the unrest of 1848. [1]

2. The boat carries some noteworthy characters

In addition to the artist’s portrayal of General Washington, the occupants of the rowboat represent a microcosm of 18th century America. They include a frontiersmen (at the bow), a Scot (second from the left facing aft), an African American (third from the left facing aft), a woman disguised as a man (foreground wearing a red shirt), two farmers (second and third from the right) and a native American (wearing buckskin and manning the tiller). Also in boat appear the future fifth president of the United States, James Monroe (clutching the flag), along with the Irish-American general Edward Hand (the man seated fourth from the right wearing a bicorn hat). [2]

3. The image is rife with inaccuracies

The artist took a number of ‘creative liberties’ in his painting. For instance, the Stars and Stripes flag portrayed in the image didn’t actually exist at the time. [3] Up until 1777, the 13 colonies had adopted the Grand Union as their standard — 13 red and white stripes with a miniature Union Flag in the upper left. Also, the famous crossing took place in the dead of night and in foul weather — not at twilight under picturesque clearing skies. Some observers have also pointed out that a wooden boat of the size depicted in the painting would have probably sunk under the weight of so many passengers and that it’s unlikely anyone could have stood up in such a small craft without tipping it. [4] In reality, Washington likely crossed the Delaware in a Durham boat, barge or bateau — not a small rowboat. Finally, the width of the Delaware at what is now known as Washington’s Crossing is much narrower than the picture illustrates. The artist based his painting on the Rhine, which is considerably wider.

One of the only photographs of the original ‘Washington Crossing the Delaware’ on display in a gallery in Breman, Germany.

4. America only received reproductions of the painting

Leutze completed the painting in 1850 and then composed a duplicate of it shortly afterwards. The original was damaged in a fire but later restored while the replica was put on display in New York. This second version was sold privately a number of times before becoming part of the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s permanent collection in 1897. Ironically, the version of the painting that famously hangs in the White House’s West Wing is a reproduction.

The painting would become a casualty of a much-later war. (Image source: WikiCommons)

5. The original became a ‘casualty of war’

The original ‘Crossing’ remained in Germany after it was painted and went on display in the Kunsthalle Bremen art museum in 1851. There it remained for decades. Sadly, it was lost in an RAF bombing raid on Bremen in 1942. Many joked that its destruction was Britain’s final revenge for the American War of Independence. [5]

What’s wrong with this picture?

6. Many complain that the painting is obscene

In recent years, school board administrators throughout the U.S. have altered textbook depictions of the painting to remove a pocket watch fob that’s shown draped across Washington’s upper right thigh. Prudish educators and parents claim that the item resembled genitals and wanted the offending bits Photoshopped out.

One of the many satirical takes on the iconic image.
One of the many satirical takes on the iconic image.

7. It inspired hundreds of knock offs

Predictably, the famous painting has spawned literally hundreds of parodies like this, or this, or even this. Likenesses have also graced everything from postage stamps to commemorative coins. It even became the basis of a 1936 poem in which each line is an anagram of the title: “Washington Crosses the Delaware”. A commemorative reenactment of the event is staged every Christmas Day at Washington’s Crossing State Park. This year’s will take place at 1 p.m. The event itself was the subject of the award-winning 2000 A&E made for TV movie The Crossing, starring Jeff Daniels as Washington. The film, which was based on the 1971 Howard Fast novel of the same name, was filmed entirely on location in Canada. The full movie is available free online here.

(Originally Published on Dec. 16, 2013)

5 thoughts on “What’s Wrong With This Picture? — Seven Strange Facts About One of America’s Most Iconic Paintings

  1. From mountvernon.org – ” #4 -Washington’s force used a collection of cargo boats and ferries to transport his men across the Delaware… Thanks to the foresight of General Washington and the actions of the New Jersey militia, the American forces had brought all available watercraft on the Delaware to the southern bank, thus denying the British the use of these crafts, while making them available for an American recrossing. Much of Washington’s force crossed the river in shallow draft Durham boats – strongly built cargo vessels, most between 40 and 60 feet in length, designed to move iron ore and bulk goods down the river to markets in and around Philadelphia. These stout craft with their high side walls were robust enough to survive the ice-choked Delaware. Heavy artillery pieces and horses were transported on large flat-bottomed ferries and other watercraft more suited to carrying that type of difficult cargo. It shouldn’t be surprising that most of Washington’s soldiers stood during the crossing since the bottoms of Durham boats were neither comfortable nor dry.” From https://www.mountvernon.org/george-washington/the-revolutionary-war/the-trenton-princeton-campaign/10-facts-about-washingtons-crossing-of-the-delaware-river/ In other words, the soldiers really did stand in the boats that they used, but the boats were not the small tipsy ones depicted in the painting (which was created in Germany in 1851). I love finding out little known facts. Thanks for the history lesson on painter Emanuel Leutze.

  2. This is an amazingly symbolic painting that captures the heart of America very well and what it means to be American, both historic and prophetic… from the farmer to the frontiersman… from the many Black-Americans that served courageously in the Revolution like James Armistead to the many brave Native Americans that Washington was well-acquainted with over the years… From common female heroines to English-American aristocrats… they all laid down their lives for the cause of freedom, each one of them knowing that if they failed, they would surely face execution.

    I find it very interesting that this painting was completed at the time when America was gearing up for her next step in the fight for freedom – abolishing slavery in the American South. While many states had already abolished it decades before, this goal, as well as the Civil War, were finally completed just 15 years after this painting with the passing of the 13th Amendment under Abraham Lincoln.

    Could it have ignited American as well as German hearts in its time? Quite possibly. It still ignites mine.

  3. Very interesting article , I expect historically visual artists have taken liberties with facts . If the crossing was actually made in the dead of night how could that artis actually light his painting . I’ve completed a WW1 novel based on Ireland’s part in that war and family history . The British had a penchant of placing Australian ,Canadian and Irish soldiers in front lines e.g Gallipoli . Of course that conflict would not have been won without the participation of The United Sates

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.